Menu Enter a recipe name, ingredient, keyword...

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Hat Cookies


The holidays can be so hectic! To keep ourselves in the right frame of mind, we decided a Thanksgiving shenanigan was in order. If for no other reason than to remind us that it’s still November. We found these adorable pilgrim hat treats on Pinterest and thought they fit the bill!

Google Ads
Rate this recipe 4.6/5 (16 Votes)


  • Keebler Elf Fudge Stripe cookies
  • Mini Reeses peanutbutter cups
  • Yellow icing


Adapted from


Step 1

First lay out your cookies face down (chocolate side up).

Now, unwrap as many Reeses as you have cookies.

Spread a layer of yellow icing on the top of the Reeses cup.

The icing should barely hang off of the edge of the Reeses cup all the way around.

Press the icing side of the Reeses onto the cookie.

Now make a square “buckle” out of your yellow icing and press it to your hat.

You'll also love

Review this recipe

Macadamia Nut & White Chocolate Sugar Cookie Caramel Apple Cookie Cups