Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Pie
2006 National Peanut Festival Overall Student Winner Melissa Huddleston Bonifay, Florida.
This is NOT the Outback Steakhouse Nutter Butter Pie recipe but after you take the first bite, you won't really care. Best part is, this pie is not as decadently sweet as the Outback's, so you can at least enjoy 1 price without keeping your cardiologist on speed-dial.
Also, I adapted the original recipe as I found it to double the filling recipe. If you want a smaller pie, just mix up 1 batch of the filling.
This is NOT the Outback Steakhouse Nutter Butter Pie recipe but after you take the first bite, you won't really care. Best part is, this pie is not as decadently sweet as the Outback's, so you can at least enjoy 1 price without keeping your cardiologist on speed-dial.
Also, I adapted the original recipe as I found it to double the filling recipe. If you want a smaller pie, just mix up 1 batch of the filling.
Find all the pictures we have received for this Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Pie recipe.
You can also send us your own pictures for this recipe by clicking on the link below.