Butterfinger Pie By dawn716 View complete recipe 0/5 (0 Votes) Ingredients 6 2OZ BUTTERFINGER CANDY BARS CRUSHED 1 8OZ CREAM CHEESE 1 12OZ COOL WHIP. THAWED 1 GRAHAM CRACKER CRUST Preparation Step 1 MIX , PUT IN CRUST, CHILL View complete recipe